Saturday, January 16, 2010

Phoenix PD attack protesters at anti-Arpaio March

We couldn't agree with Sal Reza more when he says, "There was provocation by some groups who came here for their own purpose to disrupt a peaceful march." We know he isn't talking about those of us in the Diné, O'odham, anarchist/anti-authoritarian bloc. Not only have we patiently marched in the marches and held the signs for years now, but how in the world could O'odham peoples, native to this land, in any way be considered outsiders? Such an assertion is ridiculous on its face. Indeed, as one of our O'odham comrades from the Diné, O'odham, anarchist/anti-authoritarian bloc sang from the main stage before the march, flanked by two other members of the DO@ bloc, no one seemed eager to denounce them outsiders. Naturally, then, we reject this allegation.

So, who is the outside faction Sal's talking about? In our opinion it must be the Phoenix Police. Unprovoked, a female officer on horseback (who later covered her name on her uniform) charged her horse headlong into the march, colliding with several people and in the process almost running over at least one child in a stroller. After attacking families and protesters, she then whipped out her pepper spray and let loose on the whole crowd, who fled the noxious spew. In the process, children were blasted with pepper spray.

After that, other Phoenix PD officers stormed the crowd, violently attacking marchers, dragging several to the ground and further deploying their chemical weapons from all directions in an attempt to justify their their aggression by nabbing a few people. Dozens were so affected that they were soaked in chemicals, having to strip off clothes to stop the burning. Street medics (not Phoenix Fire Department) and other protesters came to each others' aid. At the end of the melee, out of the more than a hundred that marched together, four of our comrades were in chains and countless others stood bleeding, bruised and momentarily stunned.

Still, shaking it off, we rallied, facing down the cops, until eventually they withdrew. We celebrated and took turns speaking out about what it's like to be under attack by a system that values property and power over people.

Indeed, during the entire march the Phoenix police had been provoking marchers. Riding bikes and golf carts into people. Pushing and shoving. For what? To keep one northbound lane open? Rather than assaulting people expressing their legitimate desires to see an end to oppression, why not shut down the street? Cops do traffic control all the time. What's wrong with PPD? Why, for instance, is it somehow possible for Tempe PD to shut down Tempe streets tomorrow for the corporate schlock that is "PF Chang's Rock n' Roll Marathon" tomorrow but not for PPD to close off a few streets so that people can assemble without threat of attack? Truly a backwards system indeed!

The police have so far put forward several different explanations for what happened, all of which contradict each other. On one channel they say that they were breaking up a fight. On another they say that people were throwing bottles. And on and on. What'll it be in five minutes, we wonder? The contradictory stories ought to be your first clue that what they're claiming happened didn't in fact happen. No surprise that the media swallowed it. But if we know they're lying, we have to wonder why anyone else would defend their actions?

Did people fight back against the police assault. We don't know because our eyes were full of pepper spray, but we wouldn't begrudge them if they did. To be charged into by a twelve hundred pound horse, while attacked by thugs using chemical weapons necessarily evokes the instinct to fight back, especially when your enemy is so vile as to assault children. Police demand the impossible from people. They expect you to allow them to attack you while at the same time demanding that you suppress your gut, human tendency to defend yourself. There is nothing "peaceful" in that relationship.

That sort of power relation is one that condemns those who resist while exonerating the violence of those from above. It reflects the current distribution of power -- a distribution we want to change drastically. This is as unnatural as fighting power without taking action. Movements, like people, have a right to self-defense. For us, that has to be in the form of direct action and civil disobedience against the system. It must be made not to work unless our demands are met. No more mediation through shady politicians. No more appealing to power through moral arguments. We can take our futures into our own hands, directly.

Still, we're not surprised that the police attacked. While it seems the leaders of the movement are eager to make excuses for police who attack children, we know that what we saw today is but a glimpse of what the cops do everyday. We see it with our own eyes. They are the outside, alien force that first and foremost defends white supremacy and capitalism. How can someone say they are organizing a "peaceful march" when they work with such sadists? Anyone who was at the point in the march where the attack took place obviously recognizes that the only physical threat to the march was from the police. No one in the march was at any time under threat from anyone in the march. Understand that and you also understand that naturally the cops were going to attack the march eventually, especially considering the militaristic fashion in which they deployed. Phoenix PD deports more migrants than Sheriff Joe and yet we are told that we ought to give them a pass so that we can focus on that clown Arpaio? We saw today just how foolish that strategy is.

In our eyes, this is but a symptom of the failure of the strategy being pursued by the movement as it is. White supremacy in Arizona goes far beyond one ancient sheriff in one county. Ballot measures attacking people of color will almost certainly pass in Arizona yet again this year with 70 or 80 percent margins. Is this Sheriff Joe's fault? Obviously not. But marches against Joe won't stop that.

We need a broader movement with a critique beyond Joe so that we can challenge the whole problem -- one that stretches from Tohono O'odham land down south to the land of the Diné up north. And everywhere in between. And we need to break from this mode of organizing that can only deliver more oppression and more violence down on our heads. No more politicians. No more working with cops. Look what it brings.

This is why we supported the call for the Diné, O'odham, anarchist/anti-authoritarian bloc. For someone to say now when it is inconvenient that we are an outside force is to replicate the marginalization that for centuries has dominated the discourse around land and movement in this region. But PCWC's native comrades didn't come from outside. They were always here. And we stand with them.


Juiceton said...

There is no excuse for the force used by the PPD today. To police a march including hundreds of children they brought horses and pepper spray. In what scenario could that have possibly ended well? I know Copwatch got some coverage but anyone else with photos or testimony please share too.

angela said...

The streets were closed down and all of the people involved in this march were allowed to make use of the whole street, both lanes...except the anarchists!! The police purposely targeted and discriminated against the Anarchists knowing that it would instigate a conflict! Why were the streets open to walk freely upon, except for the Anarchists? POLICE INSTIGATION!! The police casued the whole conflict and disturbed the peace again!

I witnessed the female officer on her horse charge the crowd for no plausible reason, threatening the safety of all the people! Did she feel that the Anarchists were taking up too much of the roadway, although all the other marchers ahead & behind were spread out the whole width of the roadway?
The police behavior today was a disgrace and a total shame!

The Aberration said...

My comments on this can be read on If anyone knows what to do about the continuing effects of the pepper spray today, that would be great! You can e-mail me at

Also, if testimony is needed.


laura said...

I was there. I got pepper sprayed. The police were antagonizing the Anarchist groups. How come there weren't any police in horses, bikes, motorcycles, golf carts, walking around the first half of the march? How come it is a good idea to pepper spray children and entire families? How come no-one is saying anything about it? What needs to happen for the media and the public in general see the evil in these actions?

Jon said...

great post

the police were clearly out to provoke the crowd

Phoenix Insurgent said...

I'd like to draw attention to the fact that I have corrected a minor error in the piece at the beginning to reflect better new information we have received. Thanks for all the great feedback. Not that we needed the cops to over-react like they did to know this, but obviously its clear to a lot of people that the sheriff's aren't the only police problem in town.

jxe602 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
BlueBerry Pick'n said...

...for pholks who want to discuss & share their perspectives & witness to the events, The Jeff Farias Show is holding open call-in to activists who were present at the protest.

Do you have opinions, information or philosophical issues regarding these events? Perhaps you're simply motivated to share your thoughts on the reporting you've seen?

The Jeff Farias Show airs between 6-9pm (3-6 Pacific) Eastern Mon-Fri. from the Phoenix studio.

Respected politicians, academicians, activists & musicians have interviewed with Jeff in the past & enjoyed a rewarding experience. Every weekday, Jeff & his audience investigate 'a better way'. Our conversations generally investigate a variety of subject matters & current events, through the lens of:
✪ art, courage, ethics, journalism, integrity & individual activism/expression,
✪ economic & social justice,
✪ sustainable community solutions,
✪ non-violent, non-confrontational dissent methodologies, including humour,
✪ determined pacifism,
✪ positivity.

Call us!:
✪ Local: 602.275.4130
✪ Toll free: 1.800.385.1566

Our activist audience looks forward to your dialogue on these issues & events.

TJFS podcasts are mounted for your enjoyment: all guests are free to distribute, spindle or mutilate their interview audio!

Your contribution to this project would be greatly appreciated by our global activist audience of international perspectives.

Spread Love!,

BlueBerry Pick'n
chief hippie wrangler
The Jeff Farias Show

U-Lock said...

I was one of the arrested and as far as what Blueberry says, we're asking all who were at the march to NOT SPEAK TO THE MEDIA about any details concerning those of us who were arrested. We are facing charges and need to deal with this without media involvement. If you saw something, were a witness, have video/photos, etc. Contact me or the other folks that were arrested (I know all who were arrested and am keeping in contact with them), you may unintentionally say something that could harm our cases. Please respect this. Thanks.